CSSP杂志已经将丁峰列为黑名单
作者：杜克林
看了新语丝140323的马甲哥的调查报告《旷世奇才：无锡江南大学丁锋》，
觉得这位丁峰教授的做法已经太过分了，实在有点看不下去了。
特别是注意到丁峰2013年在Circuits, Systems and Signal Processing
(CSSP) 杂志发表过两篇论文。作为该杂志的Associate Editor，不久前杂志主
编 M.N.S. Swamy 要求我们从2012年和2013年发表的论文中提名三个最佳论文奖。
按照目前的评价标准，丁峰的两篇论文应该很有机会获得最佳论文奖。由于丁峰
的做法已经超出了我们能够接受的底线，我刚刚给主编写信建议不要把最佳论文
奖授给这些作者。信件内容如下：
From:
kelin_du@hotmail.comTo:
swamy@ece.concordia.caSubject: Please remove Feng Ding(or Ruifeng Ding or Rui Ding) from
awards list
Date: Mon, 24 Mar 2014 00:15:33 +0000
Dear Prof Swamy
Recently, you asked us to nominate best paper awards.
For nominations of best paper awards, I recommend that all papers by
Feng Ding, Ruifeng Ding, or Rui Ding (Jiangnan University) should not
be awarded. I have just read an article on Feng Ding's scandal from
www.xys.org, which is most famous website reporting on academic
scandals.
Feng Ding has Web of Science citations of 4776 times, but 80% are from
himself. Over 90% are from his own team or friends, and over 95% are
from China. In order to have some citations from other authors, Feng
Ding also published papers in name of Ruifeng Ding and Rui Ding, and
then cite Feng Ding's papers.
Ding, Ruifeng and Ding, Rui have published two papers in CSSP in 2013:
1 Parameter and State Estimation Algorithm for a State Space Model
with a One-unit State Delay
Gu, Ya; Lu, Xianling; Ding, Ruifeng
CIRCUITS SYSTEMS AND SIGNAL PROCESSING, Vol 32, No 5, pp: 2267-2280,
DOI: 10.1007/s00034-013-9569-4, OCT 2013
Among the 66 references, 38 references are Feng Ding's.
2 An Auxiliary-Model-Based Stochastic Gradient Algorithm for Dual-Rate
Sampled-Data Box-Jenkins Systems
Chen, Jing; Ding, Rui
CIRCUITS SYSTEMS AND SIGNAL PROCESSING, Vol. 32, No. 5, pp:
2475-2485, DOI: 10.1007/s00034-013-9563-x, OCT 2013
Among the 55 references, 42 references are Feng Ding's.
Ruifeng Ding, Rui Ding, and Feng Ding are actually the same person,
with the same affiliation (College of Internet of Things, Jiangnan
University) but difference email addresses. From the university's
information, all the awards from the university on Ruifeng Ding and
Rui Ding are claimed by Feng Ding. From the faculty list of the
university, there is no Ruifeng Ding or Rui Ding at all.
Please do not consider any award to Feng Ding (or Ruifeng Ding or Rui
Ding).
Best regards,
Ke-Lin Du
Xonlink Inc.
在收到信件之后，主编 M.N.S. Swamy立即回复如下：
Date: Sun, 23 Mar 2014 23:15:01 -0400
From:
cssp@encs.concordia.caTo:
kldu@ieee.org;
kelin_du@hotmail.comCC:
cssp@ece.concordia.caSubject: Re: Please remove Feng Ding(or Ruifeng Ding or Rui Ding) from
awards list
Dear Dr. Du
Thank you for bring this to my attention. I will make sure that none
of his Feng Ding's papers is considered for any award. Further, I
will also keep an eye on any of his submissions to CSSP.
Swamy
很明显，现在CSSP杂志不会考虑给予丁峰的任何论文最佳论文奖，同时主编也把
该作者列入黑名单。
